WHY ALTERNATIVE FUELS?
Growing concerns about energy
security and exhaust gas emissions from vehicles have increased interest in
alternative transportation fuels. One likely candidate for this is electricity.
The development of the electric
vehicle has been an ongoing process for many years. However, the California
Air Resources Board (CARB) Low Emission Vehicle(LEV) program has accelerated
the development even more by passing legislation that requires at least two
percent of the vehicles sold in 1998 meet zero emission standards. At this time,
the only vehicle capable of such an achievement is the electric vehicle.
Current battery technology
is the major setback for the electric vehicle. At this time a battery pack can
weigh anywhere between 800 pounds and 1800 pounds. The lifetime of a battery
is also a problem. The vehicles run for only a short range before the batteries
must be recharged by a 120 to 240 volt electrical outlet. However, many of the
auto manufactures and battery producers are working towards the advancement
of battery technology.
As an interim solution to
the deficiencies in the range of the current batteries, the hybrid electric
vehicle has been developed. This vehicle is an electrically charged battery
pack, coupled with a small internal combustion engine, capable of producing
minimal emissions with a longer range than that of a battery run vehicle alone.
Ultimately, the hybrid electric vehicle design is to be a cost-effective, highly
efficient, ultra-low exhaust emission vehicle capable of equaling or exceeding
present vehicle performance, safety and customer appeal standards.
HYBRID VEHICLE CONFIGURATIONS
- Hybrid cars have two
power sources, mostly an engine and an electric motor. There are usually two
on-board energy storage systems: a fuel storage tank for internal combustion
engine and a battery for the electric motor. In hybrid vehicles, flywheel
is used as a short-term energy storage device. In hybrid vehicle concept combines
local zero-emission driving with long distance driving on the engine.
- There are two different
approaches in hybrid vehicles, the series and parallel arrangements. The difference
between them is basically related to the power transmission from the on-board
auxiliary power unit (APU). In a series hybrid electric vehicle, electric
power unit transmits the power to the road. In a parallel arrangement, the
power transmission from the APU to the road can be achieved mechanically.
In other word both electric drive unit and APU can transmit power to the road
by applying different configurations.
Advancements in Battery
Technology:
Once the battery technology
in the electric and hybrid electric vehicle is refined, the possibilities for
these vehicles are endless.
Currently, the lead-acid
battery is the most widely used for this type of application. An international
group of battery manufactures, who have formed a consortium to help advance
the lead-acid battery technology, have outlined some research goals that they
hope to achieve. These goals are not designed to help the electric vehicle reach
the same range and performance standards set by the internal combustion engine.
Instead, they have set goals that would be achievable in light of the current
lead-acid battery technology.
- Increase the specific
energy from 35-45 Wh/kg to 50 Wh/kg at a three hour discharge rate
- Improve the cost per
battery pack at $150 per kilowatt-hour
- Improve the specific
power of the vehicle to 150 W/kg at 80% depth of discharge.
- Improve the life cycle
of the battery to three years or 500 cycles of the simplifies federal urban
driving schedule with less than 20% capacity loss.
- Improve the rapid charging
technology so that the lead acid batter can be fully recharged in less than
four hours, 80% recharged in fifteen minutes and 50% recharged in five minutes.
Although the lead-acid battery
is the leading battery used in electric vehicles today, there are many other
options available. The nickel-iron, sodium-sulfur, lithium-sulfide, nickel-cadmium
and zinc-air batteries are all being tested in electric vehicles and perform
quite well. These various types of batteries are expected to increase the driving
range and power in the electric and hybrid electric vehicle, but will cost considerably
more. Continued research is needed to improve the battery driving range and
reduce weight problems.
ADVANTAGES OF EVS
- Electric vehicles produce
far lower emissions than any other fuel. They produce no tailpipe emission
and even when the emissions from the electric generating plant are considered,
EVs still rank the lowest.
- The electricity used
to power electric vehicles is readily available and can be produced from a
wide variety of sources including coal, natural gas, nuclear, solar and various
other power sources.
- The resources used to
power electrical plants are abundant here in the United States. Thus, greatly
reducing our dependence on foreign resources.
- The "refueling" of the
vehicle is convenient. An electric vehicle can be recharged at home by methods
similar to plugging a major appliance into a 120 or 240 volt electrical socket.
- Electric vehicles have
many small advantages to gasoline powered vehicles. The vehicle is easier
to maintain, runs more quietly and is subject to special incentives such as
subsidized or special parking .
Production
DISADVANTAGES OF EVS
- The cost of the vehicle
is the greatest problem facing the electric vehicle. The price of an electric
vehicle can average between $5-$10,000 more than a comparable gasoline powered
vehicle. The batteries are expensive to replace and the cost per gallon equivalent
to recharge the batteries is around $3.72. While utilizing a hybrid electric
vehicle can bring this cost down, it still does not come close to competing
with gasoline powered vehicles.
- The performance of the
electric vehicle is lacking in many areas compared to conventionally fueled
vehicles. The top speed of an electric vehicle is 65 miles per hour and the
acceleration is slow. There is also a great deal of power loss while heating
or cooling the interior of the vehicle. Another factor is that the batteries
are bulky and they take away much of the cargo space.
- The limited range of
an electric vehicle is also a major setback. For one charge, the average range
is approximately 60 miles. However, this can change due to the outside temperatures
as well as the amount of heat or air conditioning that is running. The battery
can lose capacity quite rapidly in extremely cold temperatures. For example,
when the outside air is around 20o F, the battery capacity is decreased
almost 50%. Here again, the hybrid electric vehicle basically solves the range
problem. With the internal combustion engine working with the battery the
range is not a major factor.
- Although the battery
can be recharged at home, it takes a great deal of time. To completely recharge
the battery, eight to ten hours is needed. An added problem to charging the
battery is the lack of an infrastructure if you are away from home. Charging
facilities need to be placed in convenient locations such as parking garages
and hotel parking areas.
- As more and more electric
vehicles are produced, the need for competent service and repair personnel
becomes greater. Training for those who will be working with the vehicles
needs to be more readily available. Also, emergency medical rescue workers
need to be trained as to how to handle an electric vehicle related accident.
SAFETY ISSUES
- The acid in the battery
can cause severe burns if the battery becomes damaged due to a collision or
misuse.
- The disposal of the batteries
may cause unique environmental problems. Although recycling is now available,
a large surge in battery usage may make the battery recycling facilities inadequate.
- The use of high voltage
needed to produce a "quick recharge", which is in the development process,
can be dangerous if not done properly.